home  wiki


This page explains, in simple terms, how Frottle works, and why it is needed.

The Hidden Node Problem

The WiFi protocol, the collective name for the 802.11a/b/g suite of protocols for Wireless Ethernet, was only ever designed to be used indoors over a relatively small area. In a long-range outdoor environment, the problems with this design become apparent and we experience the Hidden Node problem. Frottle is an application that can reduce or eliminate this problem.

Collision Avoidance

On any network, computers and other networked devices (called hosts) cannot make sense of multiple messages if they arrive at the same time. On a wired network, a host will first check that there is no other traffic on the network before transmitting its data. This is called Carrier Sense Multiple Access with Collision Detection (CSMA/CD) ( External linkExplainer ). On a wireless network, a host cannot transmit and receive data at the same instant, so CSMA/CD will not be effective. 802.11b/g use the Carrier Sense Multiple Access/Collision Avoidance (CSMA/CA) method whereby a host will first transmit a message, called a Request To Send (RTS) to the intended recipient. (External linkExplainer ). In a BSS network, this is the Access Point (AP). If the AP senses that the airwaves are clear, it sends a Clear To Send (CTS) message back to the host. The host then sends its data.

An Indoor Deployment

An Indoor 802.11b deployment

In an indoor environment where all wireless hosts and the AP are close to each other, the CSMA/CD method works well for coordinating traffic. Every host can receive the radio transmissions of every other host, and so traffic is coordinated.

Hidden Node Indoors

Hidden Node Indoors

Even in an indoor environment, Hidden Node can be a problem. If one host, or node, wanders out of range of all the other nodes on the network, it cannot coordinate its traffic directly with the other nodes. It must rely directly on the AP and use RTS/CTS packets to know when to transmit. In a network with a small number of nodes, RTS/CTS packets are generally successfully in preventing the Hidden Nodes from interrupting traffic flow. But when many hosts are connected, and those hosts are transmitting/receiving a large volume of traffic, the RTS/CTS packets themselves start to collide.

Hidden Node Outdoors

Hidden Node Outdoors

In a long-range, outdoor environment, in almost all cases no node can hear the transmissions of any other node, except the AP itself. All nodes are relying on the RTS/CTS method. The more nodes connected means more traffic volume at the AP and a greater probability of RTS/CTS packets colliding. When RTS/CTS packets collide, all nodes stop transmitting for a moment, and then send their RTS packets again. In very congested situations, this can cause all traffic to stop for considerable periods of time, making the network unusable.

What Frottle Does

Frottle Outdoors

Frottle uses the Linux Netfilter firewall in all hosts on the network to delay traffic. Frottle uses a Media Access method similar to that of a External linkToken Ring network. The trasmission of all traffic on all hosts, including control packets, is done in a coordinated fashion, so no collisions should ever occur.

Back to MelbWirelessRouterProject

Version 2 (current) modified Mon, 26 Jul 2021 12:49:29 +0000 by Dan
[EditText] [Spelling] [Current] [Raw] [Code] [Diff] [Subscribe] [VersionHistory] [Revert] [Delete] [RecentChanges]
> home> about> events> files> members> maps> wiki board   > home   > categories   > search   > changes   > formatting   > extras> site map


 Remember me.

> forgotten password?
> register?
currently 0 users online
Node Statistics